This paper delves into the surprising Hindu parallels between the narratives and theological understandings of Five Persons in the Biblical (Adam, Cain, Noah, Abraham, Moses) and Hindu (Swayambhu Manu, Indra, Vaivaswat Manu, Rama, Krishna) traditions. Despite contemporary theological differences, 75% of the narratives and 82% of theological understandings during the time of these figures exhibit striking parallels. The study suggests a historical connection between the two religions, emphasizing a common heritage that could foster deeper understanding and dialogue amid today’s religious conflicts.