Skip to content
Common Prophets of the Jews, Christians & Muslims and Hindus

Common Prophets of the Jews, Christians & Muslims and Hindus

  • Home
  • Stories
    • PERSON
      • ABRAHAMIC
      • HINDU
      • INTERFAITH
    • AREA
      • WORLD
      • INDUS VALLEY
      • WEAST ASIA
    • SUBJECT
      • GEOGRAPHY
      • HISTORY
      • PHILOSOPHY
    • TEXT
      • HINDU
      • BIBLE
      • QURAN
      • INTERFAITH
  • Papers
  • Reviews
    • Hindu
    • Biblical
    • Islamic
    • Archaeologist
  • Video Gallery
  • Author
  • Contact us
  • हिंदी
  • Toggle search form
Historicity of the Garden of Eden

My study suggests that the origin of the Biblical and Quranic religions lies in the Indus Valley and that Moses led the Exodus from there, rather than from Egypt. There is no archaeological evidence of the Hebrews in Egypt around 1446 BCE, the time traditionally associated with the Exodus. In contrast, the Indus Valley Civilization collapsed around 1500 BCE, which led to its people spreading in all directions. Some of these people went to West Asia and they became the Jews.
Moses carried the memories of Adam, Noah, and Abraham from the Indus Valley and that these figures originally lived there.
The Mausala Parva of the Mahabharata mentions that Krishna left for an unknown country after the Yadavas killed each other. This unknown country was Israel, implying that Krishna is Moses and that this individual led the Exodus from the Indus Valley to Israel.

  • Jacob kose jewish environmental educator b a in reader engagement cornell university Biblical
  • B.r. Mani director general national museum & vice chancellor national museum Institute new Delhi Archaeologist
  • Common Origins of Christians, Muslims and Hindus? ANCIENT WORLD
  • Are Caduceus Snakes Hindu Nadis Abrahamic
  • Saraswati River of the Rig Veda Area
  • Mohammed Mushtaq Tizarwi A.P. Department of Islamic studies Jamia Milia Islamia Islamic
  • Kalpa, Manvantara and Yuga AREA
  • Were Noah and Manu the Same Person? GEOGRAPHY

Were Abraham and Rama the same person?

Posted on January 26, 2024August 26, 2024 By Bharat Jhunjhunwala No Comments on Were Abraham and Rama the same person?

Separation of Abraham and Lot

Separation of Rama and Lakshmana

After his return to Ai, Abraham and Lot had a conflict. Their herdsmen fought with each other and they decided to separate. Lot went to live at Sodom while Abraham went to live at Hebron.

Similarly, Rama was engaged some secrete consultation with a Sage after his return from Lanka. He had posted Lakshmana as a doorkeeper to ensure that no one enter the consultant chamber at that time. Sage Durvasa came to Ayodhya at this same time and wanted to meet Rama. Lakshmana did not want to allow him to see Rama but Durvasa threatened that if he would not let him see Rama Immediately, he would curse not only Lakshmana but also the entire city of Ayodhya. Lakshmana was in dilemma. He thought is better that he alone be punished by Rama for allowing Durvasa to enter Rama’s consultation chamber, rather than entire Ayodhya being cursed. Thus he allowed to Durvasa to visit with Rama. Then Rama decided to brake his relations with Lakshmana because he had violated in his junction. Thereafter, Lakshmana left went to bank of the Sarayu River, held his breath and ended is worldly journey. Rama and Lakshmana separated just as Abraham and Lot.

Separation of Rama and Lakshmana

Abraham begot two sons named Ishmael and Isaac from Hagar and Sarah After his return to Ai, while Rama begot two sons named Lav and Kush from Sita.

Abraham’s Sacrifice of son
Lav and Kush coming to Rama’s Horse Sacrifice

Sometime later, God commanded Abraham to offer his son in sacrifice. Abraham accordingly bound his son to the sacrificial altar. At this time a messenger stopped Abraham’s hand. Abraham saw a ram nearby and sacrificed the ram instead of his son. Sarah died sometime after this event.

This could be parallel to Lav and Kush coming to a horse sacrifice being done by Rama. Lav and Kush were living away from Rama at that time because Rama had expelled Sita from Ayodhya. They came to Rama’s horse sacrifice as bards and sang of the life of Rama. Thereupon Rama asked Sita to come to place of the sacrifice and Sita was taken into the earth.

In both narratives a sacrifice was undertaken involving his son(s); and wife died thereafter.

Abraham  lived away from their wives at the point of her death 
Rama lived away from their wives at the point of her death 

Abraham was living somewhere else when Sarah died. He “came” from there to mourn for Sarah. Sita was similarly living at Valmiki Ashrama when she died. She came to the place where Rama was undertaking the horse sacrifice and was taken into the earth at this time. The wife was living away at the time of her death in both the narratives.

Silences in Bible and Ramayana

Another parallel is that Jacob, grandson of Abraham, went and settled in the south after the latter’s death. Rama’s son Kush similarly settled in the south. He was made the king of South Kosala.

These similarities aside, there are certain narratives in Bible and Ramayana about which the other text is silent. Three such narratives in the Bible are the battle between four versus five kings; the destruction of Sodom; and Joseph going to south. On the other hand, the Bible is silent about the conquest of Bharata and Shatrughna over Gandhara and Mathura. These silences do not create a contradiction between the Bible and Ramayana. These narratives can be inserted in the other text without creating a dissonance.

 

We give the parallels between the Bible and Ramayana in green colour in the table above and the distinctions in red colour. The parallels are as follows:
1 Both returned to Ai or Ayodhya from the south.
2 Abraham and Lot separated just as Rama and Lakshmana.
3 Both had two sons.
4 Sarah and Sita were separated from the Prophet.
5 There is an association of the son with a sacrifice.
6 Sarah and Sita were living away from Abraham and Rama when they died.
7 Sarah and Sita were both buried.
8 Grandson Jacob and son Kush settled in the south.
Could then Abraham and Rama be the same person?

Visit our website: https://www.commonprophets.com/

For Videos: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCN4sb3toJxNGPjmSubnwz_Q

ANCIENT WORLD, AREA, HISTORY, INTERFAITH, INTERFAITH, PERSON, SUBJECT, TEXT

Post navigation

Previous Post: Is Abraham’s Monotheism Consistent with Rama’s Monism?
Next Post: The Semitic religions—Judaism, Christianity and Islam?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join our WhatsApp Group

Subscribe Posts

Buy Now Our Book

  • Buy Amazon Rs 400 for India
  • Buy Amazon $ 6.12 for Kindle
  • Buy Amazon $ 19.99 for Other
  • Challenges of Living Traditions in Identifying Prophets or Avatars ANCIENT WORLD
  • Reincarnation in Islam Abrahamic
  • Are Noah and Manu the same person? ANCIENT WORLD
  • Understanding Devtas and Astrology in Hinduism Area
  • Abraham was Brahma or Ram? HINDU
  • Unequal West versus Unequal Islam? ABRAHAMIC
  • Swami Avimukteshwranand ji. Hindu
  • River Identities in Rig Veda, Ghaggar as Sarayu and Yamuna as Jordan AREA

Common Prophets of the Jews, Christians, Muslims and Hindus

Address: Lakshmoli, Kirti Nagar, District Tehri, Uttarakhand, 249161, India

Phone no : +91-9917144777

Email: bharatjj@gmail.com

Recent Post

  • Allah or Brahman are the same
  • Hindu Idol Worshippers are not kafir
  • Reincarnation in Islam
  • Concordance of Islamic Concepts of Allah and Malaa’ykaas and Hindu Concepts of Brahman and Devtas
  • Does Quran reject idol worship?

Visitor counter

Search

Copyright © 2024 Common Prophets of the Jews, Christians, Muslims and Hindus.